Not so tiny dancer
I have always hated dancing, ever since Morag McIntosh and I ran out of our ballet class at the age of 7 and vowed we would never go back. I still feel woefully self-conscious dancing, even if we’re just talking about standing in a crowded club and jiggling a bit. I hate it, I can’t relax, everyone’s looking, I hate it I hate it I HATE IT. Did I mention that I don’t like dancing?
I love to watch people dance, though, if they’re good. In fact, let’s watch some good dancing now:
I’d love to dance like that, but I can’t. Not even close.
My aversion to dancing began long before my weight gain. I just never liked it. And yet somehow, over the last eight years, it has become all about weight. I blamed my complete absence of any sense of rhythm on the fact that I am overweight and cannot move quickly enough. I blamed my inability to perform certain steps on the fact that I am carrying too much weight to be flexible. It’s all about being fat, you see. Fat = bad at dancing. Thin = good at dancing.
Dancing is supposed to be a good way of improving your general grace and balance, and I am woefully lacking in both, so I decided to take up bellydancing. I chose bellydancing because, as everyone knows, it is fat friendly. You NEED a belly to bellydance. Bellydancing is for fat people! Everyone knows that! So you can imagine how thrilled I was when I walked into the classroom last Saturday to discover that everyone else in the class was a stick. Seriously. They were lovely women but not only was there no one as big as me, there was no one who had a belly, and that includes the instructor. She had a belly in the same way as Kate Winslet is considered to be a plus sized actress. It was as if I had nicked all of the bellies and shoved them under my top.
Looking at myself in the mirror sort of made me want to cry and run out the room, but I’d paid for the term in advance so I was buggered if I was giving up. And it’s just as well I didn’t, because when we started dancing, I could see that we were all actually pretty much at the same level, and by “level” I mean “utterly shit”. Think of Shakira. Now imagine her standing in for Michael Jackson in Thriller. That’s what we looked like as the instructor sashayed backwards and forwards in front of us, arms wafting delicately in and out, wiggling her no-belly, with the rest of us stamping and crashing about behind her, arms out like sticks, rolling precariously every time we stood on tiptoe.
We were crap. I was crap. The others were crap. It was just… crap. We all looked dreadful. It was great.
I found this strangely comforting. I took even more comfort in the fact that at the end of the class, when we were stretching, I was the only person who was able to bend over and put the palms of my hands flat on the floor without bending at the knee. YES! Me! The token porketeer! TAKE IT BITCHES!
I don’t know why I think that weight has anything to do with dancing, or with flexibility. At the Jamaican Dancehall classes I used to go to there were at least six or seven girls in the class who were much bigger than me; a couple of them would probably have been classed as morbidly obese, and they were fantastic dancers: 100% on the beat, fantastic sense of rhythm, they looked fabulous when they danced. One of them could do the splits. For some reason I had assumed that only thin people could do the splits. Because it’s like every other physical activity, isn’t it? If you aren’t thin then you can’t be fit, and if you aren’t fit then you can’t be any good at sport - and that’s borne out by the fact that these days professional dance is, with a few exceptions, the province of the ultra-skinny. Look at Cyd Charisse in that video - she was considered to be very thin indeed back then, and I would kill for her figure, but there’s no way a woman her size would get anywhere in professional ballet now. I mean, yes, she may be an electrifying dancer - but can you count her vertebrae? Can you see her ribs? You can’t even see her knee bones! What a fatso!
Anyway, I still hate dancing. I don’t feel good doing it, I don’t feel sexy or pretty. If we’re talking about taking joy in physical movement, I get more out of boxing or rowing. But I’m sticking with it because I want to get better - I’d really like to be more graceful - and the way to get better at dancing is not to come back when you’ve lost weight, it’s to grit your teeth and keep practising. I am determined to get it into my stupid head that it is not because I’m fat that I feel this way. It’s because I’m not very good at dancing, just like lots of thin people aren’t. LISTEN TO ME HEAD.
Man, what a great clip! That whole scene was really cool!
Comment by Ed R — May 16, 2008 @ 12:43 am
I should also say this- good for you, Katy. I dated a belly dancer for a bit in my 20’s. She was constantly lamenting the lack of size on most women in her classes. She really wanted to get the idea out that belly dancing was for everyone, not just for girls skinnier than the grass in their skirts ( she taught hula, too ).
Comment by Ed R — May 16, 2008 @ 12:46 am
Oh I like that sentiment, Thank you.
Comment by manda — May 16, 2008 @ 11:18 am
It is a great clip, isn’t it? I love Cyd Charisse in everything, but I think this is my favourite scene of hers.
Comment by Katy — May 16, 2008 @ 8:07 pm
Yay for dancing! Go you! I think you will enjoy it more as you get better at it and don’t feel like you’re struggling all the time - with salsa it’s the same and it always amazes me that people anyone sticks with it for the first few lessons.
I cannot remember a time when I haven’t hated the way I look, and so I always felt like dancing was off limits to me (like expressing an interest in boys, appearing to try to look nice, or being happy). I absolutely refused to dance in front of other people - in fact nothing was more terrifying. Then when I was 22 or so I had a sudden conversion experience when I was with a group of new people (who didn’t know I didn’t dance) involving having a big panic attack and running away into the forest (I like to be dramatic) and then somehow allowing myself to be convinced that actually no-one was looking at me. That night I started dancing and I’ve never looked back. Dancing is one of the things that makes me happiest in all the world.
On the other hand, it is still depressing sometimes. I live in Mexico so salsa and similar gets danced at basically every party. I know I’m a pretty good dancer by general standards, but some nights I just get sadder and sadder watching all my thin friends get asked to dance, even the ones that are no good. Partner dances are a bitch that way, given that you’re placing your ego in the hands of a bunch of men. I should totally take up belly dancing!
Comment by Eloise — May 16, 2008 @ 10:06 pm
Take it from me - skinny != good dancer. Me as a child? Stick. Stick insect stick with sticky arms and legs and knobbly knees. All stick, just like Mr. Balanchine wanted (bastard). My older sister? Shorter than I and builds heavy muscle. Result? 7 (SEVEN!) years of ballet classes and I was still crashing around. My sister? Superb ballet dancer asked as a child to join the Royal Ballet infants program or whatever it was.
Because I looked like I should be able to dance everyone expected I could and so my pathetic heaviness (which also has nothing to do with weight - biggest girl in my class was the most fabulous, light footed person I’ve ever met. Beautiful thing) strikes them as being even worse than it is.
My mother claims it was all worth while because I have, “lovely upright posture!” Yeeees…. but wise people duck if I start waving my arms around and at a concert I’m the only one standing stock still and nodding my head to the beat because anything else will endanger those around me and cause instant immolation through the shame of Dancing Badly In Public.
Yay for you and your wonderful, dreadful class of belly dancers. When my sister took up belly dancing I sent her a tasteful belly-dance costume kit (Item: one ginormous* red bra with stitching on each cup in the shape of a hand; Item: One super-sized packet of plastic googly eyes to be glued to former to the taste of the owner; Item: One packet of nasty plastic bling for same purpose; Item: one bottle tequila with worm) and I would totally do the same for you.
*My sister does have the traditional ballerina lack of boobs. I tell her it’s because all those pirouettes she did sucked ‘em back in thanks to centripetal force.
Comment by Megan — May 16, 2008 @ 10:36 pm
I trained professionally to be a ballet dancer, and certainly wouldn’t say that size precludes you from being a good dancer. I gained a LOT of weight when I stopped (ate crap basically). Now I am training in ice dance and I started skating at my heaviest weight - it has never impeded me, and as I lose weight (3 stone so far), it doesn’t get easier!
By the way - have you ever seen the French & Saunders spoof of that clip? It’s worth looking at . . .
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hsrIkcwu9vA
Comment by Amanda — May 17, 2008 @ 7:59 am
Fab clip - she’s teensy though, even by today’s standards.
Check out this one (I love it!) - shoot the choreographer perhaps… and the wardrobe mistress!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WLenuBXt2RE
I loved that everybody was crap and that you did it anyway - good for you!
Comment by sooz — May 17, 2008 @ 11:18 pm
Yay, lovely clip.
I hate dancing too. I have no grace or coordination, and as for moving my arms at the same time as my legs… wtf?
My dad loves to dance, and I have an infuriating family full of ballroom-dancing freaks who always try and grab hold of me and do the dancing-whilst-holding-hands thing at weddings, making it impossible to just dance quietly by yourself in a corner without being accosted. And God, if I’m bad on my own, I’m ten times worse when I’m expected to marry my movements with someone else’s. I just seize up.
To be honest, I hate teamwork generally (it’s a control-freak thing). That dreaded phrase during yoga classes or workshops: “Find a partner.” Oh help. Can’t I just do it on my own?
Still, I do like dancing when I’m so off my head I forget all the insecurity stuff, stop thinking about what I look like and just move my body to the music. It still looks shite, I just don’t care.
Comment by clare — May 19, 2008 @ 10:57 am